Which Way then, Maronite Man?

Qadisha-Holy-Valley

Throughout their long history, the Christians of Lebanon, and especially the Maronites, were either self-governing themselves or fighting for self-determination. After the catastrophe of Kafno, they sought the security of a grander Lebanon, compromising their independence in favor of a partnership that they hoped would ensure their future.

Unfortunately and predictably, the Lebanese Republic’s century-long experiment has devolved into a structurally failed state, one that no longer safeguards the survival, freedoms, or prosperity of its founders.

A Total Collapse

As detailed in Volume I of our book “The Maronite Cause”, state failure manifests across interlocking metrics. It starts with the erosion of the monopoly of force, where militias and parallel states supplant sovereignty. It moves to fiscal and administrative impotence, evidenced by chronic debt, corruption scandals, and a 2019 default that vaporized the savings of an entire nation.

All of this comes on top of infrastructural decay, blackouts, and contaminated water, forcing citizens into survival mode. On top of all that failure, judicial dysfunction makes accountability impossible and allows impunity to reign in cases that matter, including high-profile corruption and murders.

These elements compound into a “total collapse,” as seen in the 2019 economic meltdown, 2020 blast, and the wars of 2023, 2024, and 2026.

This irredeemable system, entrenched by veto mechanics, sectarian bargains, and external meddling, renders the Republic not just useless to Maronites and Christians but actively dangerous.

Clinging to illusions of partnership or top-down fixes ignores the longue durée of concessions that transformed self-governance and autonomy into second-class status for Christians and Druze. Clinging to the false hope of reform isn’t only delusional, but it also wastes valuable time we could use to advance our cause.

The current republic’s hardware is designed to convert every program and reform attempt into negotiated paralysis.

If reform from within cannot produce a viable country with legitimate Rule of Law, then freedom and dignity for small communities like ours become discretionary favors, and not fixed rights. When that happens, our existence in the East is put under the mercy of others and their agendas – even if those others are our fellow citizens.

Therefore, we should turn, calmly and openly, to an entirely different architecture.

Where Do We Go from Here?

The good news is that Maronites and the rest of the Christians of this Mountain have the history, the culture, the geography, an the will to carve their own destiny and create a solution that works. What they lack are institutions that transform their will into action and discipline.

The historical evidence we presented across hundreds of pages in our book, culminates in a simple proposition: survival of a small nation needs the guarantees of a functional and effective state.

The Lebanese Republic cannot provide us with such guarantees. Its center will always be ruled by militias, and will always be capture-prone and impunity-ridden.

What should we do then? Should we cling to a false hope while our communities disappear? Should we do nothing while we become second and third-degree citizens in this failed republic?

It is time to envision different solutions.

It is our right to live in a state that guarantees our livelihood and rights. It is our right to live in a state that has no security exceptions, where our lives, freedoms, and property matter. It is our right to live in a state with auditable finances, rights-bound policing, utilities that work, and justice that cannot be vetoed by anyone, and especially not by other sects or armed militias.

It is time to be courageous and envision a state that is ours. One that is small enough to be honest, disciplined enough to be lawful, and strong enough to be left alone.

We envision a country that can guarantee what the old machine cannot: that a child’s schooling, a monastery’s chant, a farmer’s title, a young person’s job, and a journalist’s sentence do not depend on a bargain, a patron, or a mood. Only then can politics become ordinary again, and freedom predictable. Only then will Christian families choose presence over departure.

If the center cannot carry its load, the mountains must carry their own. And they can. The Maronites and Christians of Mount Lebanon have been scarred, marginalized, and impoverished by this republic, but they are not erased. The only path forward is the one that leads us back to our roots, back to our homeland.

It’s time to turn from diagnosis to blueprint, from understanding to action. It’s time to explore, without fear and without apology, practical models for Christian self-determination, whether we talk about federal arrangements or complete partition.

Our next step as a community, no, our sole duty, is to chart a course toward prosperity and renewal in a crumbling republic. Which way will it be then, Maronite man?

——————-

This article is an excerpt from The Maronite Cause book Volume I. Our books are available on these links:

The Maronite Cause Volume II – Free PDF edition

The Maronite Cause Volume I – Free PDF edition (Amazon)

The Maronite Cause – Paperback Edition (Amazon)

The Maronite Cause – Kindle ebook Edition

More information can be found on: themaronitecause.com

Leave a comment